I'm unsure what my feelings are

Written by
JazzyPearlEarthCakePanInBudapestWithAffection
Published on
Wednesday, 21 May 2025
Category
Share

The story

So, I'm currently in a long distance relationship since several years, and I'm also very happy with my partner. Aside from occasional small conflicts, which I imagine are part of any relationship, there aren't any things that make me unhappy. I love him and we have a very good chemistry, we talk transparently about any issue that comes up, and i can imagine staying with him in the long term. Overall I'd say I'm the happiest I have ever been in a relationship.

Although recently I got a message from my ex-girlfriend after 7 years of silence, which also happens to be my first partner ever, but our past is a bit more complicated. For context, we were an on-off couple, which honestly was because she broke up with me every time she found an issue in our relationship. And I absolutely see that those issues were caused on both sides. Both of us were immature at that time, since we were 17 and 19 when we got together, and with my knowledge from today this was probably her way of coping with problems, removing them from her life or running away instead of facing them. There also was family drama and mental health problems she was struggling with, which made it even harder to talk about issues with her. At some point we had a bigger argument and she blocked me and cut all ties for good, that's when the 7 year gap happened.

So much for the negatives, but we also had a lot of similarities in our personality and interests. I could talk with her like I could with no one else back then, and it often felt like the cliche of "having found a soulmate". I can't say if that was just the experience of being in love for the first time or not, and I certainly don't want to make comparisons with my new partner, since there has been too much time, changes of circumstances and personal development happening in between those two relationships.

So when she reached out to me I was very surprised at first, because I thought I would never hear from her again, and I also was fine with that. She basically said she wanted to find closure, apologized about her mistakes and behavior, and we had a bit of small-talk about our work and stuff. At first I thought "okay, I don't care about this person anymore, I'll accept her apology because I have good faith in everyone and I'm glad she reflected on her personality, so she deserves getting the closure she wants".

However I start to feel more and more unsure about my actual feelings. It's not that I feel in love, but there seems to be this kind of "fascination" (idk how else to put it) when seeing pictures of her, like seeing an old friend and wondering what they have been up to for the last 7 years, and you just want to hang out with them to hear all their stories. The things is that I had those same feelings of fascination when meeting her for the first time, and it's what later then turned into us being together.

This is on my mind all the time ever since we talked again, I'm having fantasies of meeting her again to catch up, and I can't tell if it's because I'm still processing it, or if it's because there might actually be feelings developing again. I'm also really happy for her to have made that step of reflecting on her mistakes, which is why just blocking her and moving on would kind of feel unfair towards her.

This is where things get a bit complicated. My current partner has insecurities when it comes to "being replaced", which I fully get and respect. He also knows we talked and didn't feel great about it, he says he respects my decisions but also made it clear that he feels uneasy with me talking to this person. For this reason I don't consider meeting up with her, or even continuing the conversation. I don't want to do anything that makes my partner feel bad or insecure.

However, I'm also a bit afraid that I might just have suppressed my feelings for her during the pause we had, and by her reaching out these feelings got unlocked again, and that's the reason I'm currently feeling those emotions I'm unsure about. It could also be that I simply feel memories of the feelings I had back then, and perhaps these memories will fade during the next weeks. My current partner doesn't know about these conflicted feelings I have, because I don't want to make him worried or even more insecure, but he knows that she reached out to me and we briefly talked.

So I know the logical solution to this would be "forget her and move on, you're happy with your current partner" or "find out which one you want to be with", but at this point I simply can't tell what those emotions are I have towards her. Friendship? Memories? Suppressed love? I simply don't know what I'm feeling, or how I should react in this situation. How do I find out what I'm actually feeling, and depending on what the result of that is, what is the "right" way to carry on? Maybe some of you have experienced something similar, or you just have an advice for me? Any comment is appreciated :)

Couple Stories


Points of view

You need to be logged in to add a point of view.
PulsatingAmberAirAlpenglowInHammeMilleWithLoneliness 5d ago

I totally get where you're coming from, dude; it's like, how do you really know what those feelings are after all these years? I've been in a similar boat. I had an ex reach out after so long, and it really stirred up all kinds of emotions. You definitely don't want to mess up a good thing with your current partner, especially if he's already feeling insecure about this.


But at the same time, curiosity and a bit of nostalgia can play tricks on your mind. It seems like you're doing the right thing by not rushing into meeting up with her or diving too deep into conversation. Just remember, emotions can be pretty deceptive, especially when someone's been a significant part of your past 🕰️. Keep that line of communication open with your current partner, even if it's difficult. You gotta stay true to what makes you happy, but also respect the relationship that’s making you happy now;

ZealousTanEarthMatchesInJodoigneWithHope 5d ago

Hey, it sounds like you're caught in a real emotional rollercoaster, but I'd suggest you focus on what you have now. "Don't throw away a diamond while chasing glitter," you know? Long-distance relationships are tough, yet you've built something solid and positive with your current partner!


I've been there, too, with the whole ex reaching out deal. Trust me, often it's just nostalgia hitting you hard, not actual feelings rekindling. Sure, it feels nice to catch up and hear what's been happening, but don't let that cloud your judgment;


Staying true to what you want and prioritizing your current partner’s feelings is key. Old emotions can be strong, but they don't define your present happiness. Stay focused on what really matters, and you'll figure it out. Keep it real and be true to yourself! 👍

FizzingNavyLightRemoteInReykjavikWithSympathy 4d ago

Dude, you gotta chill! Like, I get your ex pops up like a ghost from the past, and suddenly you're all twisted up, but don't go messing up the good stuff with your current partner, ya know? That "fascination" ain't love, it's your brain playin' tricks 'cause of old memories!


Happened to me too, my ex hit me up outta nowhere after years, and it was like—what the hell?! But you gotta remember why it didn't work out in the first place!!! You and your ex had loads of issues, and it's not just magically gonna be different now. Don't forget, you're sayin' you have crazy good chemistry with your current partner...why risk that for some déjà vu kinda vibe with your ex?


You gotta be real with yourself; stop fantasizing and focus on what's in front of you! Keep it real. You don't want to hurt your partner, especially if he’s feeling insecure. Stick to what makes sense and what makes you happy now. Don't let some old flame set your mind on fire!!! 🔥

ElectricSilverLightNotebookInBogotaWithAnticipation 3d ago

It's understandable you're feeling torn, but rekindling things with your ex might not be the wisest course of action!!! Remember why you moved on in the first place; six years is a long time, and people don't always change as much as you hope.


Allowing old relationships to invade your current happiness could be detrimental, especially when there's "occasional small conflicts" in your present relationship that seem manageable. Communicating openly with your current partner about any lingering doubts or feelings might bring more clarity and reassurance than diving back into past drama. Your current partner deserves full transparency; they're the one you're building a life with now. It might be just old emotions resurfacing, but it's crucial to address these feelings without causing unnecessary upheaval. Look forward, not backward—it's rarely worth the drama.?!