am i wrong for how i confronted my dad?
The story
so today my brother asked my dad if it was fine for him to go to the beach with my mom instead of going to the gathering with my dad. my dad for some reason flipped out and got so angry. he called my mom and screamed at her for 1-2 hours. my mom was already at the beach but didn’t have time to enjoy anything whatsoever. later on the dinner table my dad was telling my siblings and i about how his dad (my grandfather) threw a hammer at him for disrespecting him. my dad explained saying “i never once regretted what my father did to me because it made me a real “man””. he went to the nearby table where my brother placed his electronics, picked his nintendo up and slammed it into the ground. everything shattered and my siblings and i were so shocked and scared. my mom as well. some of my sisters started crying and yelling at my dad which caused me to cry aswell. my dad took my brothers phone and slammed it on the floor aswell. my dad acted shocked that we were crying. he said we are over reacting and whatever. they explained to him that these aren’t normal things that he is doing. and that we have been suffering from him ever since we were kids. he told us to say what was in our hearts. what we have been holding for our entire life. when it came to me? i just couldn’t say anything. i told him that. that i have nothing to say. but in reality i wanted to tell him i much i hated him and how much i wanted him to die. but based on what he did to my sisters. i know if i say something he will just keep going and trying to make me the wrong one. when it came to my youngest sister to speak she said that what he is doing is so childish. my dad looked like he wanted to kill her. talking about how “rude” she is. mind you we were all crying at this point. after everything that happened he took the rest of my brothers electronics and went down to his office. we started bursting into tears next to our mother and then we heard a slam, then another. he actually broke my brothers ipad and playstation. we went to my oldest sister’s room and stayed there while my mother went to talk to my dad. we sat for about 40 minutes when he came up to the room and sat down acting like he did nothing wrong. talked to us calmly. about how he wont changed. and this is our luck that we got a dad like him. before he left he told my brother that he will take my brother’s tv and break it as well. he also said that what happened and what we did to stand up for my brother is “wrong” and that we should repent. my mom later went down to the living room to go away from all the disasters but my dad followed her there and started fighting again. this is when i’m writing this. it’s currently 3am and all i hear is screaming. tbh i’m kind of relieved to hear my mom scream. i’m always scared that one day it will stop. and i would come down with her laying on the floor with blood everywhere. i just feel like my dad would do something like that.
in my dad’s defense he said that my brother is not a “man” because he can’t “talk/speak” well like the other kids. but then he told my sister that she should stop comparing him to other dads because it will only bring her pain. and i’ve had a habit of recording anytime my dad screams. so as soon as he started i hid my phone under the table and recorded everything. as you can tell it’s not his first time doing something like this. not to this extent ofc but once when my brother was 9-10 my dad wanted to teach him how to ride a bicycle. after a while of my brother failing my dad hit him over and over until my brother peed himself.
i’m so tired. so tired. i’m still i minor and so are my siblings except my oldest sister. my dad claims that what he is doing is the right way of teaching us. he sees us as a disappointment. i don’t know what to do. my mother tried divorcing so many times but she couldn’t. i’m dying inside. i want to die and end it all. but then again. i would bring shame to this family for killing myself. because in my dad’s eyes, he did mothing wrong.
so tell me is my dad wrong? is he abusive? if so what kind? am i being brainwashed washed into thinking this is the only right way? what can i do to stop this? i’m so tired and i son’t know what to do.
Stories in the same category
Points of view
it seems there might be a misunderstanding of the father's intentions, which could be rooted in cultural or generational differences. while the situation described certainly indicates a high-stress environment, it is important to remember that people can change and grow. during my own childhood, my father also had a strict approach, but over time, through open dialogue, our relationship improved significantly. it might be beneficial to focus on constructive communication within the family to foster understanding and healing; this can be achieved by expressing feelings in a safe manner. every family has its challenges, and often, they provide opportunities for strengthening bonds. hope and patience can be powerful tools in addressing these issues. keep faith in the possibility that your family can find common ground and move forward together.
SizzlingBlackWaterCuttingBoardInDubrovnikWithConfusion
2d agoi completely agree with your insights and perspective! it's so true that sometimes cultural or generational differences can cause misunderstandings 🤔; every family has its own set of challenges, but as you said, they can also be chances to become closer. with open dialogue and a bit of patience, positive change is possible!!! communication is key, and expressing feelings safely is an essential step. it's heartening to know that people can grow and change over time 🌱✨. let's keep hope alive for brighter tomorrows and believe that families can find their way to common ground.
wow,, reading this, i can relate... totally. my own family had moments like this😔 i think your father is definitely displaying abusive behavior. breaking things, yelling, it's all indicative of negative reinforcement…. but it seems like he's unaware of the harm he's causing.. in my opinion, such behavior can lead to long-term emotional trauma. i remember my cousin faced similar issues; his dad also thought he was doing the right thing. it’s really hard to understand how this is « teaching ». the household's environment feels very toxic and, honestly, quite damaging... i hope they find a way to address these issues constructively. it's difficult to see a positive outcome right now though...
wow, that sounds like a pretty intense situation, but I mostly agree with how you see it!!! your dad's actions seem a bit too harsh and it's understandable why everyone is upset; it's not easy dealing with someone who thinks they're "teaching" through fear. i've seen families go through stuff like this, and it's tough, no doubt. but don't lose hope!!! remember that change is always possible. "every cloud has a silver lining", so maybe this could be a turning point for your family. stay strong and keep your head up! you never know how things could turn around 🙂!