My daughter recently switched to a new private school which organizes an inaugural school trip in August each year. Sadly, she missed this year's trip but she's keen on joining next year's three-day adventure to Philadelphia.

The hitch, however, is the limitation on hotel room occupants: no more than six individuals per room. Right now, there are 37 girls needing accommodation. We discovered a group of four students who normally only participate during the day (three girls and one boy) but actually stay overnight in the same hotel. They too are part of the trip, under the guardianship and funding of their parents due to past bullying issues, especially directed at the boy. Their arrangement includes two rooms — one for the students and one for the supervising parent.

They've kindly offered for my daughter to join them in their arrangement. She's all for it, while I'm hesitant, particularly due to the mixed-gender sleeping arrangement, which I find completely inappropriate.

We've debated this for weeks now. Firm facts are in place: no school-arranged rooms are available, a private room arrangement like the independent group’s is financially out of reach for us, and the notion of a mixed-governight stays a firm no. Consequently, attending the trip isn't feasible.

This has utterly shattered her. She’s blaming me for making her switch schools in her sophomore year and our frequent relocations which she feels have destabilized her social life. She's finally looking forward to settling and making lasting friendships, and now this trip feels crucial to her. However, as much as it troubles me to see her upset, the decision seems final, though my husband is now suggesting we perhaps reconsider, given all the adjustments she's had to endure.

If our family saga were ever turned into a reality show, I suspect the audience would be split. Some viewers might empathize deeply with my daughter's desire for normalcy and friendships. Others might rally behind our parental concern over mixed-gender stays. It'd sure spark some heated debates on parenting forums and social media!

Should mixed-gender student trips be allowed?