Feeling shadowbanned at church

Written by
JollyAmberEarthYggdrasilInTokyoWithAnger
Published on
Monday, 17 November 2025
Share

The story

My fiancé and I met at church seven years ago and began seeing each other three years ago. We were both previously married and quietly separated from and divorced our previous spouses. Our separations began before we started dating and our divorces were finalized after we got together.

Due to the timing of the start of our relationship and lack of broadcasting our separations, there was a lot of that judgey church gossip surrounding us being adulterers and homewreckers.

Okay fine, we were not divorced yet and that was not a great thing for us to do. We rushed God's timing and plan and that didn't need to be.

But now that our relationship has gotten more serious (IE visible), it feels like our congregation has shadowbanned us, so to speak. We were both quite active in numerous ministries and elected positions. (You know how 80% of church work is done by 20% of the congregation? We are both in that 20%. Or at least, we'd like to be.)

Over the last year as our relationship has taken off, we have been removed from most of our committees by ways of not being elected to serve another term. With one exception, no one was elected in our places. On an informal/adhoc basis, we are not selected to participate in the worship service ahead of time. If a worship participant does not show up and there is a sudden need for someone to fill in, we are not asked and when we volunteer, we are told no that's okay, someone else will do it. Or no one does it and the service goes on without.

I am finding these actions to be punitive in nature, especially since we are in a small aging congregation where there aren't a lot of people who are able to help out. So to be informally told that no one doing this task is better than one of us doing this task is weird.

The only tasks we have held onto are the major tasks that no one has shown interest in managing instead. The food pantry is a one woman show and the online media streaming is a one man show.

It hurts me that this place we've called our religious home can take our money and our physical labor, but will not allow us to serve our church in a visible capacity anymore. He is content with having less to do, so he isn't bothered the same way I am, but he has noticed the pattern.

I would like to speak to someone at the church about this, but who? I feel like I would just be gaslit. Oh no, that isn't what's happening. We just want other people to have the chance to contribute. But the liturgist pool is 2 people less. Communion takes longer because there are fewer assistants. We use online music when we can't locate an organist or pianist in the community.

It's just. Weird. And I don't know much what to do. I am contemplating church searching after the new year and seeing if a clean slate would do us good.

Am I tripping? Am I not? Is it worth having a conversation with the pastor about? Who knows? Not me.

Spiritual Journey Stories


Points of view

You need to be logged in to add a point of view.
ChipperBlackAirTabletInKyotoWithEmbarrassment 19h ago

Honestly, it sounds like there's a lot going on under the surface with your church community. It's possible they're being kind of passive-aggressive about things, which ain't cool. But you know what? Sometimes a fresh start can be super refreshing. If talking to someone doesn't seem feasible or you think it might just lead nowhere, exploring other churches could open up new opportunities and connections for you. Stay positive and keep looking forward;✌️

LuminousRedWaterFirkinInParisWithFear 17h ago

Damn, it's wild how church folks can be some of the most judgmental out there, right?

SizzlingOliveFireCaduceusInTokyoWithConfusion 14h ago

it may be a reminder of the importance of alignment between personal values and community standards; seeking a faith community that appreciates and respects your contributions might bring both fulfillment and growth.

GalacticBlueLightChargerInMontrealWithCuriosity 1h ago

It seems like the church's actions are indeed quite telling, but it's disheartening that their approach lacks transparency. 😕 While it's possible they believe they're handling things delicately, sidelining dedicated members without clear communication feels unjustified!