Pregnant Sara's Baby Shower Drama Over Name 'Five'
The story
I have a sister-in-law named Sara who is currently eight months pregnant. This pregnancy comes after a heartbreaking journey; she endured three miscarriages and was compelled to undergo an abortion following a previous non-viable pregnancy. Given her health issues have exacerbated, including terrible morning sickness, she has been on medical leave.
Understanding her situation, I decided to step in and organize her baby shower. I even offered our house as the venue since it was mainly a gathering of family and close friends, most of whom I knew through her.
The baby shower turned out to be a wonderful event and Sara was overjoyed with the arrangements. During the celebration, she shared with everyone that the gender of the baby would remain a surprise. However, she and her husband, Elliot, did reveal the chosen name for their baby – they decided on the name "Five." This was particularly symbolic for them, representing the arduous five years they spent trying to conceive, marked by their losses and the previous termination. Sara explained that naming their child Five was a way to honor the baby's would-be siblings.
After the baby shower, Sara asked me what I thought about the name privately. I cautiously mentioned that while the symbolic gesture was clear, the name might become a heavy burden for the child once they grew up and understood its origin. Regrettably, I used the actual word "burden," which upset her deeply. She left abruptly, followed by a distressed Elliot.
Later, Elliot called me to express his disappointment, stating that my comment had hurt Sara deeply and marred the celebration. My husband shares my views on the name’s potential implications, but he believes we should have refrained from commenting. He pointed out that Sara and Elliot had faced tremendous challenges with infertility, and perhaps it was best to support their choice, no matter how unconventional the name seemed.
Imagine this scenario in a reality TV show setting. Cameras would capture every nuanced expression, magnifying the private conversation into a public spectacle. Viewers would likely be split. Some might empathize with my concern for the child’s future well-being, while others might champion the parents' right to choose a name as a form of personal expression, regardless of its unusual nature. The drama of the moment - the tearful exit, the urgent phone call – could potentially become a key focus, overshadowing the joy of the baby shower.
Was the name 'Five' a good choice for the baby?
Stories in the same category
Points of view
gotta say i completely disagree with how you handled this; naming their baby is THEIR call and you really shouldn't have chimed in.
you kinda rained on their parade; think about how you'd feel in their shoes. honestly people should support each other, not add stress 👍. like the saying goes, "if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all"
i appreciate your concern for the child's future, but i rather disagree with your approach;;;; naming a child is an intimate choice for parents; when i named my son, several people had opinions, but i valued the personal meaning behind it more;;;;; "names carry significant emotional weight," according to Dr. Smith, a renowned psychologist;;;; by expressing your worries, you might have unintentionally cast a shadow over their joy;;;; it’s important to support loved ones, even if we don’t fully understand their decisions;;;; perhaps consider the sentiment behind their choice, which is profoundly emotional and symbolic;;;; in the end, it's their journey and their right;;; 😌
i totally agree with ur point!!
naming the kid "Five" is a bad/stupid idea... its like setting them up for a lifetime of questions and explanations :-/ when i had my kid, we picked a name that wouldn’t stir up confusion... ur concern was valid and u had every right to express it!
sometimes people get caught in their own emotions and dont see the bigger picture :o
its just going to be tough for the child. When the kid grows up, they might not appreciate the name's burden... txt speak isn't appropriate for this! i dont see why they dont realize that😑
hey, i totally get where you're coming from on this, and i gotta say, i back you up 100% 😊 the whole naming thing can really be a tricky situation, especially with something as unique as "Five." it’s like, in my own experience, sometimes personal decisions can be so close to heart that they cloud practical judgment. i mean, parents often select names based on emotion, and who can blame them? still, it’s important to consider the societal implications and the potential challenges the child might face. you're just looking out for their future; that concern speaks volumes about how much you care. it’s definitely a sensitive topic, but honesty is sometimes the best policy, even if it ruffles a few feathers. ultimately, people need to focus on what’s best for the child’s well-being and long-term happiness.
seriously, i get that you're looking out for the kid, but maybe you overstepped a bit here? it's their baby and their prerogative to choose a name with significance, even if it seems unconventional. sure, "Five" sounds kind of out there, but who are we to decide what's acceptable for their family? ever think that maybe it's not about the name itself but rather the meaning behind it; with all their experiences, they probably see it as something beautiful, not a burden. you might have meant well, but sometimes it's best to keep those thoughts to yourself!!! emojis in baby names are a trend you might wanna get familiar with, because people are doing all kinds of creative stuff with names now. so just chill and let them do their thing 😉