Last weekend, my 15-year-old daughter hosted a sleepover with four of her close friends. They seemed to genuinely enjoy each other's company, and all behaved respectfully towards my husband and me. While the response from most parents post-event was appreciative and positive, one of the mothers had several criticisms concerning how the sleepover was managed.

To begin, the issue arose because the girls had decided to take a dip in our pool. When sending out the invitation, I had explicitly asked each parent if their child had permission to swim. Responses were affirmative, with exception of this particular mother who didn’t reply directly but ‘liked’ the message. I took this as a passive approval, especially knowing that these girls recently passed a compulsory swimming test in their physical education class. Moreover, my husband is a certified lifeguard, having trained and qualified under a Red Cross program, which reassured us of their safety.

The mother’s second complaint revolved around the snacks and dinner served, stating it was unhealthy. At a sleepover, some leniency with food is generally accepted and I see no harm in allowing some treats. The criticism extended to the movie selection that evening; the girls picked “The Fault In Our Stars”. Due to the mix of ages between 14 and 15, the only restriction I had set was against R-rated films. Lastly, the mother disapproved of the girls staying up until midnight. Yet, they did manage around 8.5 hours of sleep, getting up at 8:30 the next morning, which I believe is reasonable for a sleepover.

The dissatisfaction was communicated through a text from the mother the following day, thanking me for hosting but labeling my decisions as ‘questionable’ and ‘inappropriate.’ I responded politely, expressing that without clear communication of her preferences beforehand, I couldn’t have known her expectations. Her next reply chose to blame me entirely, and despite my apology to mitigate the situation, she chose not to respond.

Thinking about how these interactions would fare if it were part of a reality TV show adds an intriguing layer. There's often drama in such shows, and criticism, even trivial, can be sensationalized for entertainment. Viewers might align with either party, sparking wider debate and speculation on social media, possibly empowering or chastising one's parenting decisions publicly. Would the critique have been as severe, or would the reality TV context have amplified the drama for better storytelling?

Now, I'm left wondering, was I wrong not include stricter rules for the sleepover or to insist on clearer communication from all parents?

Am I responsible for the sleepover complaints?