he cheated
The story
I found out he cheated because an email from Bellweather Grill popped into my inbox while I was clearing pharmacy reminders. The subject said, "Thanks for celebrating your anniversary with us," and my first dumb thought was that the restaurant had mixed me up with another customer. Then I opened the attached receipt. His name, our rewards account, his usual ribeye, and a candle dessert were all there. I have never even been inside that place. My hands went cold so fast I nearly dropped my phone.
The date printed near the top was last Monday. That was the night before my endoscopy, when I was home in old sweatpants trying to finish the awful lemon prep drink. I had asked him to stay because the instructions made me nervous and I kept getting sick. He said, "I can't babysit, work is slammed," then kissed my forehead and left with his laptop bag. I believed he was catching up at the office while I sat on the bathroom floor with a towel and my phone.
The receipt was for $186, including wine, a shared appetizer, and the anniversary dessert. There was also a note from the server: "So sweet meeting you both!" That line got me. Not just sex or some random meetup, but them sitting there acting like a couple while I was scared about a camera going down my throat. He had even texted me from the table asking if I had finished the prep. I kept staring at that message and the little candle charge on the receipt;
When he came home, I put the receipt on the kitchen counter beside the broth I hadnt touched. He went pale and tried, "It's not what it looks like." I asked who she was. After a lot of staring at the sink, he admitted he had been seeing a woman from his gym and said the anniversary note was "her joke." Apparently the joke included him wearing the blue shirt I bought for our own anniversary. I saw it in a photo the restaurant had reposted, tucked in the corner behind another table. 🙃
I didnt yell. I called my sister, and she came over with her crossword book and took me to the procedure the next morning. He sat in the living room while I packed a bag, saying we should talk when I was less upset. The nerve of that sentence almost made me laugh. My sister told him, very politely, that the person who skipped my prep night for a fake anniversary dinner did not get to decide when I was calm enough.
Right now I'm at her apartment, eating plain toast and reading the receipt like it might change. It wont. I hate that a loyalty account told me more truth than the man sharing my home, but I also feel weirdly clear. My procedure results were fine, my sister has my back, and I know I can untangle the lease even if it gets messy. I dont want revenge or a huge scene. Should I leave a note and be done since he cheated, or hear whatever excuse he has ready?