Hopeless romantic seeks guidance for "situationship?"

Written by
BubblingGreenLightningSycophantInMontrealWithRegret
Published on
Wednesday, 24 September 2025
Category
Share

The story

Ok, here we go...I'm stuck in this rut of how do I proceed from here kind of thing. In a nutshell, I've been friends with this guy for about 4-5 years now, but we really started becoming best friends over the last two years. We're both in our 30s. About 7 months ago we started really hanging out more and having weekend movie watching sessions and dinners. He would reach out to me more then and engage in conversation, as well as asking to hang out. We never got past the cuddling stage, but I could definitely feel the chemistry and attraction between us. I know we were both holding back because I was just finishing up a divorce and I wasn't yet officially single. About 5 months ago, I got brave and admitted having feelings for him. We are both very open with each other about anything on our minds. The conversation was cordial, but he stated that he didn't know if he felt that way about me and wanted to "cool" things off because of the fact the divorce wasn't official yet. I completely understood from a moral perspective and respected that (not looking for judgement on this though). The kicker part is when we continued the convo, I flat out asked if he would ever see a future with us in it or if the idea of "us" is out of the question. He said he didn't know, and couldn't see into the future, but he wasn't going to close the door on the idea of there being an "us". He also is the type of person who would say if there wasn't a chance. So naturally, you can see how this gave me hope.

We didn't hang out as much after that and we still don't as frequently, BUT here's the kicker part(s): we still talk almost every day (even if he's not as talkative as he was in the beginning when things felt newer), he still confides in me, I still get invited to go with him to visit with his parents every other weekend (his parents/family loves me), we'll get quick dinners together, he's gifted me several things in the last two months, etc. Basically what is missing from before is the amount of quality alone time we get. Maybe he isn't committing to that because he doesn't want to give the wrong impression, but when we aren't in a busy phase at work/life, he will actually reach out suggesting getting back into watching shows together. I also wonder if he doesn't want to jump into anything because I'm still only a couple months divorced and he doesn't want to give others the impression that I got divorced to be with him (which isn't the case. he was not the reason for my divorce in the least)

SO THIS IS WHERE I'M STUCK. I'm so smitten with him, and have never felt this way about anyone, and don't have anyone else in my life, so on one hand I kind of say to myself, I'll take what I can get. On the other hand, I wish I could just walk away and give it some distance to let him figure out if he wants me to be that special someone in his life. He hasn't been in a relationship in A WHILE, so part of me also wonders if he's just super used to his solidarity and is really out of practice. My mind always asks myself, if there was no possibility of us being a thing, wouldn't he have just said that there was no possibility of that instead of saying he wasn't "closing the door" on that potential? Also, if there wasn't the possibility, why would he go to the lengths he does with certain things still? IDK! These are things that I feel people our age wouldn't do if they were "just friends" with each other and my close friends/family agree.

If you've gone through something like this, or had someone you know go through this, or you're genuinely just good at reading people and situations and have advice/opinions to offer, I'm all ears!

Love Stories


Points of view

You need to be logged in to add a point of view.
TrippyRubyFireBoustrophedonInBrasiliaWithAnger 23d ago

It seems like you're in a bit of a gray area here, but I think sometimes people just enjoy the company and comfort of someone familiar without necessarily wanting to take it further; however, as the great philosopher once said, "You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take," so maybe it's worth having a heart-to-heart conversation with him to clarify where things stand?

CuriousSilverWaterWineOpenerInKrakowWithJealousy 23d ago

honestly, this guy sounds like he's stringing you along. i've dealt with people who can't make up their minds and it's exhausting. if he really wanted to be more than friends, he'd have made a move by now. trust me, keeping someone in limbo isn't fair—either he's in or out. personally, i'd say give yourself some space to figure out what *you* want without his mixed signals clouding your judgment. 🙄

FizzingMagentaLightDrillInHanoiWithRegret 23d ago

It sounds like this guy is really valuable to you, but the mixed signals are messing with your head; maybe it's time to focus on yourself for a bit and see if stepping back helps him realize what he wants too!

SizzlingRubyShadowObeliskInFlorenceWithDespair 23d ago

it's a tough spot you're in for sure, feeling all these intense emotions but getting that back-and-forth vibe from him. seems like there might be deeper feelings on both sides, but maybe he's just processing stuff slower than you are. sometimes ppl need more time to figure out their own emotional landscape. and it could be he’s genuinely afraid of messing up something good by diving into a relationship when things are still kinda fresh with your divorce. 😕 giving it some patience might help, but also don't forget to prioritize your own happiness and well-being while you wait this out!

ShiningSteelBlueFireIconoclastInHanoiWithSurprise 23d ago

Honestly, it sounds like you're overanalyzing and reading too much into his actions! maybe he genuinely values your friendship but doesn't see it evolving into more...

CrazyChartreuseWaterSmartphoneInNairobiWithEmpathy 22d ago

Hey, I totally get where you're coming from! It sounds like a classic case of "what are we," and those can be super tricky to navigate; when my best friend went through something similar, she realized sometimes people just need more time to sort out their feelings. Your guy seems genuinely invested in you as a person, which is definitely a green flag, but it’s tough he hasn’t made up his mind yet. Staying friends while also subtly exploring other aspects of your life might open doors you didn't expect—who knows what new adventures could come from that! Maybe try finding ways to enjoy the time together without too many expectations hanging over it, because life's short and sometimes it's the journey that's worth holding onto rather than racing towards an outcome. Plus, keep in mind how important self-care is during times like this; make sure you're not losing sight of your own happiness outside of this dynamic!

ZanyMagentaWoodAirPurifierInLimaWithAmusement 21d ago

it appears you're caught in a precarious dilemma where emotional investment and ambiguous signals are interwoven; while his actions suggest a level of affection, they lack the definitive commitment you seem to seek.

SerenePearlWaterHypnopompicInOsakaWithEmbarrassment 21d ago

I totally get how confusing this can be, but sometimes the best thing is just to lay everything out on the table and have an honest chat about where you both stand; it's like one of those moments in a rom-com where clarity comes only after everyone talks openly—and who knows, maybe it'll clear things up or help you decide what your next move should be!

SparklingMaroonWaterWhiskInEvoraWithSadness 20d ago

post-divorce can be really complex, and it sounds like you're in a unique situation where both of you might be guarding yourselves for different reasons; maybe consider having an open conversation about how his presence impacts your healing process and see if that helps either of you figure out what you're truly looking for.

MelodicTurquoiseMetalDragomanInAlentejoWithAnger 19d ago

hey, i get that this situation is super complicated and emotionally draining. honestly, it kinda feels like he's sitting on the fence here. maybe he’s keeping things open 'cause he doesn't want to lose you, but not sure if he's ready for a relationship yet. 🤔 it's totally possible he’s just comfortable with how things are now and unsure about taking the leap. sometimes stepping back a bit could give both of you some clarity, but make sure it doesn’t compromise your own emotional health in the process. keep communicating openly if you feel stuck, but also consider giving yourself some space to see if his actions become clearer when you're not so close to the situation!

FantasticLemonFireJuggernautInPragueWithDisgust 19d ago

Man, you’re in quite the situation here! Sounds like this dude is really keeping you on a rollercoaster of emotions. Maybe he’s into you but scared to mess up the friendship, or possibly he's just enjoying having his cake and eating it too. I mean, who wouldn’t want someone who listens and cares without committing? If I were you, I’d take a solid look at what you're getting out of this while waiting for him to decide—it shouldn’t just be breadcrumbs of affection. Honestly, testing the waters elsewhere might give you clarity on what you truly want and deserve in your life.

HummingGreenEarthChargerInBeijingWithLoneliness 19d ago

It's intriguing how the emotional dynamics in your situation involve a blend of ambiguity and potential, as if you're navigating an "emotional paradox;" perhaps his hesitance stems from an internal conflict or fear of vulnerability, which can be quite common post-divorce.

ShimmeringPeriwinkleFireDeskInSanFranciscoWithPride 19d ago

sounds like you're in a tough spot!! navigating post-divorce feelings while trying to gauge someone else's emotions can be quite the rollercoaster; i've been there myself. feels to me like he does care for you deeply—but might not be ready to dive into anything serious because of your recent divorce or his own relationship hiatus; that doesn't mean he's not interested, just cautious. sometimes actions speak louder than words, and it seems like he's showing he values having you in his life by keeping you close with family visits and gifts; trust me, these are genuine signs of appreciation! whatever happens, remember to keep focusing on yourself too—personal growth during this time can lead to unexpected happiness outside of this current situation!

DazzlingBlueWaterCoffeeFilterInViennaWithLoneliness 18d ago

navigating post-divorce emotions is understandably tricky, especially when you're entangled in such a unique bond with him; it seems like he's weighing the complexities of love, friendship, and timing all at once. his actions do suggest some level of affection beyond mere friendship🤔 yet without explicit commitment, this limbo can be emotionally draining. perhaps he needs to reconcile with his own stance on relationships given his time out of the dating pool 🤷‍♂️ meanwhile, enhancing your self-awareness about what you truly want might illuminate paths you hadn't considered before; pursue personal growth and remain open-minded—it can catalyze unexpected opportunities for personal fulfillment! keep fostering your well-being as a priority while navigating this emotional labyrinth 💪😊

WhisperingRoseWaterHeaterInJodoigneWithDespair 18d ago

wow, it sounds like you're really in a tough spot; but honestly, maybe he's just trying to be respectful and cautious given the timing of your divorce. it's possible that he’s still figuring things out for himself too, especially since it's been a while since his last relationship. i was once in a similar situation where the other person seemed unsure, and eventually, when we both gave each other some space, things became clearer for both of us. sometimes taking a step back can help you see things from a different perspective and might prompt him to realize what he truly wants. whatever happens, remember to prioritize your happiness and emotional well-being first; life's way too short not to chase after what makes you genuinely happy!

FunkyGoldLightningQuasarInCairoWithCuriosity 18d ago

navigating relationships post-divorce can be tricky and emotionally intricate. it seems like your friend is genuinely fond of you, demonstrated by his consistent presence and gestures; however, these actions might not necessarily translate into romantic intentions. perhaps he's enjoying where things are currently without the pressure of defining the relationship.; friendships evolving into something deeper often require redefining boundaries and mutual willingness to pursue a future together. in my experience, open communication and setting clear boundaries could guide both of you towards clarity—whether that's as close friends or something more.

GoldenLemonWoodCuttingBoardInAucklandWithSurprise 17d ago

hey there! it seems you're dealing with a real head-scratcher 🤔 you two have such a strong bond, but the uncertainty can be frustrating. maybe he's just as confused about his feelings and needs time to sort them out 🤷‍♀️ in situations like this, patience can be your best friend. keep being honest about how you feel, but also focus on activities or hobbies that bring you happiness outside of this relationship—sometimes they provide the clarity we need! hang in there, and remember, life's twists often lead us where we're meant to go 😊

EternalPearlWaterBedInAthensWithFear 16d ago

I hear you, and it sounds like you're knee-deep in a bit of a whirlwind; from what you've described, I think there's a chance that he genuinely values having you in his life but might be cautious about moving forward due to your recent divorce and maybe even his own hesitations;.

SapphireAmberEarthCalendarInSevilleWithEmpathy 16d ago

Honestly, it kinda sounds like you’re both in this middle ground where neither of you wants to rock the boat too much. You’re right; people don't usually do all those things he does if they're just friends and there's no chance of more. Maybe he's just trying to balance between what he feels and what’s socially acceptable after your divorce. I've been in a similar situation myself, and sometimes you gotta weigh if the emotional investment is worth the uncertainty or if it'd be better to take a break for some clarity; if nothing else, you'll learn a lot about what you're willing to put up with!

ShimmeringTanEarthPalimpsestInCapeTownWithEmpathy 16d ago

It sounds like your friend's actions show a mix of affection and caution, which can be confusing as heck!! 😅 He might genuinely appreciate your companionship but could also be struggling with his own emotional readiness for a relationship; you're just out of a divorce and he's been solo for a while, so it's understandable if both of you are moving carefully. It might help to have a heart-to-heart about where each of you sees this going, even though it feels daunting—setting clear expectations could provide some much-needed clarity in this emotionally complex situation!!!